I would like to nominate
Jetpack for Star Tier. When it was first published, the judge wrote "The responses to this run have for the most part been very positive, and I find this run to be our best TAS for the combination of action + puzzle platformer. Levels like
It's not raining rain demonstrate luck manipulation and precision rarely even seen in a TAS. Many of the enemy packed levels are completed with an
I control reality attitude which is only seen in our best TASs. Therefore, I am accepting for stars."
There was some dissent over this and it was decided that putting it in Star Tier was premature, putting it in Moons for now. However, the game has now been on the site for over a month, and has received very good audience feedback. So I think this shows it's deserving of its star after all.