Old question:
Did you like watching this movie?
After read now 2 threads, I think I must start a topic about this. I think the question is wrong and maybe should be changed.
Reason 1 is this thread:
#1003: Diman's NES Gradius in 13:25
More people voted yes. But in the message they write it sound like that they only like to watch the movie, but don't think its publishable. Not sure, if they mean it this way, but it sound a bit like it. Maybe I just understand it wrong.
Reason 2 is this thread:
#993: fuzi2's SNES Star Ocean in 1:53:13
Here more people voted no. They don't like to watch the movie and I understand the reasons. The movie is more a message skipping and show near no action and the language is japanese and when you don't know this game its hard to follow or understand whats going on. But I think its publishable at all, because it show how fast you can beat this RPG and this is great.
So I think the question should be different. More like this:
Do you think this movie is publishable?
or maybe mix it with the old question
Do you like the movie and think its good enough to get published?
Then maybe the votes are different by some movies.
Sure its too great, when the movie is entertainment and fun to watch. But some movies are just great, because they are classic games and everybody know them. It can be, that in some movies its impossible to make them entertainment and great to watch. But when its good played and most like the game, why not publish it anyway.
I think in the past it has work good with this question. But meet the requirements for this site get harder and harder as I see in the last month. In the past a movie was good, when it looks good for many people. But more people want the best possible result and a near Frame perfected movie.
This is only what I think and some things are just my opinion. I will noone attack for his opinion. I only want to know what other people think about this. It sound in some messages that more users think the question is wrong so why not ask here in a topic and write the own opinion.
Edit: Sorry when I post it in the wrong forum. Maybe should moved to the Sites forum. Forget this forum as I post this topic.
(PS: my english is not perfect, so the grammar is maybe a bit wrong. I hope someone understand what I try to say with this topic)