I agree with Warp and Radiant.
PS: Maybe we should move this discussion to an new thread?
Maybe forget the star thingy for a personalized list and just allow an user to put movies in a list and allow him to categorize his list?
Another thing: I think you should think remove the history of this entry for the long lists. The history of this entry is very interesting for movies. But not list of movies in my opinion.
This idea was voiced a few days ago on IRC. We ended up with the need to let the users put personal stars to certain movies.
Yeah it's like what I meant: something other than a list of rated movies. But I think it should be unrelated to stars in some way because I'd like to put somes runs in a particular list so I can find it easier.
feos wrote:
The amount of stars the user has must be 10% of the total amount of movies he rated. Obsoleted movies must be accounted I think.
This is an idea to force members to rate more movies. However, I strongly disagree to have a fixed personnal stars quota. I don't want to have to vote 100 runs so I could star my 10 favorite runs.(or 200 so I can star my 20 favorites runs)
feos wrote:
If some movie gets much user stars, it's a great indication it must be starred officially
I like this idea! We could make the star list to generate with the movies that gets starred a lot? Like: Take the most starred movie of X Platform, etc. Or simply the most stars of every platforms. Etc.
feos wrote:
And having a limited amount of those stars one can make a list that really makes sense, because one just can not handle a list of HUNDRED favorite movies properly. Feel free to disprove and discuss.
Who is going to star 100 movies? Nobody. Also, if we implement a categorization system, handling a big list is easier.(If I had to do it, I'd categorize 100% togheter, any% togheter, etc.)
• Only registered users can rate movies. (Note: the rating list also doubles as a personalized favorite list.)
I have a small problem with this: I don't really call the list generated as a personalized favorite list.
I think a separated list should be done: A personalized list in which you choose it content, and the list of rated movie.
A new icon that says: add to favorite to each publication page. And the list I'm suggesting will simply list them... And of course allow the user to categorize or organise them.
Why it should be separated in two lists?
-Hard to search a specific run(a favorite run or a special run for example) in a big list where it ordered by publication date if they have the same score.
-Won't have a huge list to scroll down(Let's say we rate every games)
-In my favorite list, I don't want the runs I rated low on it(obviously it's not a favorite, and yet it's in the list)(And that's the reason I don't rate movies except my favorites: I really don't want a huge list where only 5 % of the movie I rated are actually my favorite runs in a list of 300 entry)
-In the current list, every run you rated is listed, even my hated runs... I don't really call that a personalized favorite list)
-Maybe other reason I'm missing.
Thoughts?
I noticed this is a handheld Platform, so I think it should be moved to the right forum. ANd also, stickied.(The 3DS wishlist also)
On topic: I think a TAS of narutos games could be interesting.
"requesting star tier" is just not something people do in threads like these. Your third point of asking 100 votes is completely impractical for anything that's not an SNES or Genesis platform game. So by your new guideline, no new games can be starred ever.
Let's not forget that only Ocarina of time, super mario world Majora mask, or Super mario 64 achieve such high votes.(I guess)
Lol... can't follow my own advice. Got Kazam working by switching the encoder. Enjoy, and please let me know what you all think!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mCeFpLMn3sc
Looks pretty neat! Ther eis just one little thing: When you play SMB, you don't see farther than the screen and that is obvious when you moved the "playscreen".
Since the start of the thread I was interested on it, Don't give up :)
I loved the run, the begenning tas a little bit boring, but the middle of the run was very fun to Watch! you got a yes from me.
I also think this run should get a star. I think thelevel achieved bu this run is a notch over the current moon runs.
Oh, I thought you changed to fly formation after being shoot of the canon.
Still, it's neat! I Wonder how the team with the crocodile would be if it was TASed. :O
Wow!
I have some questions: Why do you alternate partners so quickly?
Also, why some times do you take the flight formation even it's the slowest formation?(Like just after being shot of the canon)
Notheless, it's unbelievable the speed you finished the level!
I think the S is superplay and not speedrun.
Superplaying a game often ends up beating the game in the fastest way possible, but somtimes, it is not.
Also, I wish you a speedy recovery!
So, how bad will Tails's story be broken?
I know it's problematic already but I want to see a TAS that destroys it.
Also, Twinkle park, was the YES. Nothing I have seen was so abusive of a game's design.
Me I want to see a TAS of each character... especially Big the Cat. Would be funny.
PS: Yes vote.
I hope to see more of your work, it's simply amazing!