I agree that the site needs a proper way of showcasing these kind of movies. In fact, we already have something similar, it's
Gruefood Delight. I think that it could fulfil the purpose just fine by getting improved and reworked, more or less deeply. As it is now, I think it mostly has just two issues: visibility and honor. Visibility because it's just an obscure wiki page, honor because these movies are officially considered as rejected.
I see that the most complicated issue to deal with is deciding
how to showcase these movies. In my opinion, it will become clearer after deciding about
how much visibility we want to give to these movies. And in order to decide that, it will necessary to first decide
how many movies should be accepted. That is, where to draw the line regarding the acceptable quality. Do we want to let in just any kind of movie, without any sort of restriction?
My concern is not just about taking out visibility from the entertaining movies (which should still remain the main highlight of TASVideos). I'm more concerned about taking out the visibility of entertaining/interesting Showcase movies in favor of boring/uninteresting Showcase movies. Sure, we could build an appropriate interface that allows to not mix up these Showcase movies together, but that would end up making the Showcase more labyrinthine.
Just to make it clear, I'm not against anything nor imposing anything, I'm just pointing out that
visibility and
inclusiveness are inversely proportional: if you increase one, you have to decrease the other. But hey, I understand that I could be completely wrong! If I would be to be proven wrong it would be wonderful, as the biggest issue would be solved! (in my opinion.)