Post subject: General screenshot discussion for publications
JXQ
Experienced player (749)
Joined: 5/6/2005
Posts: 3132
Here is the status of this ongoing project. Please leave input if you have an idea for a screenshot, criticism on one that is currently up, or know of a run that does not have a screenshot (or is a duplicate). New publications without a new screenshot (verified through 1071M) Genesis Streets of Rage N64 Tony Hawk 3 - I'm unable to make this game look correct, although all my plugins match. If someone else can give this a screenshot, or me some advice, that'd be great. NES Air 2 Gimmick! Maniac Mansion - This appears to be one of NVA's desynced screenshots, need to verify that Ninja Crusaders SNES Super Punch-Out!! Other suggestions for updating NES Legend of Zelda - According to Baxter, the second quest TAS has a screenshot from play from the first quest Recently updated: NES Excitebike SNES Wild Guns Original post:
I realize that I've done quite a few of the screenshots on the site, and chances are that some of them are not the greatest. So I'm starting this thread to have a place to talk about screenshot suggestions to any publication on the site. Now that NesVideoAgent takes automatic screenshots of many submissions, this will hopefully reduce the number of published runs without a screenshot. Here are a few of my opinions on screenshots: 1) I don't think that there are many cases where a screenshot from a previous movie should carry over onto the next movie - only on very small improvements. Currently, there are many movies which have the screenshot of the movie they obsoleted. I'm going to work on fixing this (except for older movies) in the coming weeks. 2) I format my filenames as follows: (Game name, possibly abbreviated)(Published movie number).png/jpg. Example: dynamiteheddy880.png 3) Even though you can see changes on the MovieMaintenanceLog, I will sometimes make a dummy edit to the text so that the change shows up on RecentChanges as well. So if you have a publication that has a screenshot you aren't happy with, or a new suggestion, or you have questions (or answers) about screenshots or screenshot policies on this site, then feel free to discuss that here.
<Swordless> Go hug a tree, you vegetarian (I bet you really are one)
Active player, Editor (296)
Joined: 3/8/2004
Posts: 7468
Location: Arzareth
JXQ wrote:
2) I format my filenames as follows: (Game name, possibly abbreviated)(Published movie number).png/jpg. Example: dynamiteheddy880.png
I approve this. As the movie number decreases clash chances significantly, even radical abbreviations for the game name are allowed (just as they were before). I don't need a dummy edit for updating the RecentChanges, but I don't know if others don't so I'm not trying to ask you to not do (3). And yes, NesVideoAgent's automatic screenshots are not always best possible compressed, though I occasionally manually crunch them (about twice a month).
Senior Moderator
Joined: 8/4/2005
Posts: 5769
Location: Away
Movies that I think could use better screenshots (off the top of my head): SMB2u any%; Mega Man; Castlevania HoD (both runs); DKC 101% (too dark); Prince of Persia 2 (showcasing glitch is good, but the screenshot itself is boring); Castlevania AoS glitched any% (basically the same as PoP2); Super Metroid low% (though that doesn't matter much as the run is very old and being improved). More to come.
Warp wrote:
Edit: I think I understand now: It's my avatar, isn't it? It makes me look angry.
Banned User
Joined: 3/10/2004
Posts: 7698
Location: Finland
Bisqwit wrote:
And yes, NesVideoAgent's automatic screenshots are not always best possible compressed, though I occasionally manually crunch them (about twice a month).
Couldn't it run them automatically through optipng or pngout?
Experienced player (821)
Joined: 11/18/2006
Posts: 2426
Location: Back where I belong
Thanks for doing this JXQ, one shot that I've always thought looked horrible was Gex 64, it's incredibly dark. I was unsure if I should even mention it because I don't want to turn this into a thread where people just complain about screenshots that they don't like, but you can't see anything that's going on for Gex.
Living Well Is The Best Revenge My Personal Page
Active player, Editor (296)
Joined: 3/8/2004
Posts: 7468
Location: Arzareth
Warp wrote:
Bisqwit wrote:
And yes, NesVideoAgent's automatic screenshots are not always best possible compressed, though I occasionally manually crunch them (about twice a month).
Couldn't it run them automatically through optipng or pngout?
Well sure it could, but it's too lazy to. :)
JXQ
Experienced player (749)
Joined: 5/6/2005
Posts: 3132
I'm a little rustier on N64 screenshots but I agree about Gecko, so I'll see what I can put together. I'm not familiar with OptiPNG. Currently I use AdvPNG and PNGout. I've tried PNGCrush and I found it usually wasn't as necessary. What I should really do is find every single program like this and write my own small script/program that will use them all automatically on every PNG in a directory. I don't know much at all about compressing a jpg for N64 screenshots.
<Swordless> Go hug a tree, you vegetarian (I bet you really are one)
Banned User
Joined: 3/10/2004
Posts: 7698
Location: Finland
Optipng is basically pngcrush but with more options, and it also can perform a more exhaustive search. AFAIK advpng, optipng and pngout use slightly different approaches and different types of tests in order to try to reduce the size of the png. While pngout usually wins, there are a few cases where optipng actually produces a smaller result. I have also noticed that for some odd reason pngout doesn't support all types of pngs while optipng does. (In those cases it's enough to run the png through optipng first and then through pngout because optipng "fixes" the png so that pngout can read it.) I suppose that to get the smallest possible size, all three programs should be run. The resulting png will be the one from the program which produced the smallest result.
P.JBoy
Any
Editor
Joined: 3/25/2006
Posts: 850
Location: stuck in Pandora's box HELLPP!!!
Warp wrote:
I have also noticed that for some odd reason pngout doesn't support all types of pngs
PNGOUT doesn't support (rarely used) 16-bit PNGs
Active player, Editor (296)
Joined: 3/8/2004
Posts: 7468
Location: Arzareth
List of non-obsoleted movies that have the same screenshot as their predecessor:
mysql> select m.id,s.abbr,mf.filename
from movie m,movie_file mf,movie_file mf2,movie m2,system s
where mf.movieid=m.id and mf2.movieid=m2.id and m2.obsoleted_by=m.id and mf.filename=mf2.filename
and m.obsoleted_by=-1 and s.id=m.systemid order by s.abbr,m.id;
+-----+---------+--------------------------------+
| id  | abbr    | filename                       |
+-----+---------+--------------------------------+
| 843 | GB      | mmii.png                       | 
| 908 | GBA     | cvhodzggzdydp.png              | 
| 919 | GBA     | cvhodcomicalflop.png           | 
| 150 | Genesis | quackshot.png                  | 
| 358 | Genesis | mikejackson.png                | 
| 464 | Genesis | neostrider.png                 | 
| 512 | Genesis | elviento.png                   | 
| 788 | Genesis | alexkidd.png                   | 
| 790 | Genesis | DarkCastleAqFaq.png            | 
| 811 | Genesis | castleillusion.png             | 
| 832 | Genesis | kingpin.png                    | 
| 881 | Genesis | mercs.png                      | 
| 906 | Genesis | contrahc_secretend.png         | 
| 945 | Genesis | gunstarheroes.png              | 
| 952 | Genesis | mickeymania.png                | 
| 192 | NES     | dragonslair.png                | 
| 193 | NES     | PowerBlade.png                 | 
| 232 | NES     | gremlins2.png                  | 
| 246 | NES     | ninjagaiden3.png               | 
| 250 | NES     | tecmobowl.png                  | 
| 259 | NES     | astyanax.png                   | 
| 269 | NES     | fax.gif                        | 
| 275 | NES     | smb1full.png                   | 
| 294 | NES     | addfam.png                     | 
| 307 | NES     | trojan.png                     | 
| 340 | NES     | kungfu.png                     | 
| 365 | NES     | blasmast.png                   | 
| 374 | NES     | mario1c.png                    | 
| 392 | NES     | gauntlet.png                   | 
| 401 | NES     | wizwar3.png                    | 
| 411 | NES     | goonies2.png                   | 
| 416 | NES     | f13.png                        | 
| 425 | NES     | cobratri.png                   | 
| 451 | NES     | iceclimber.png                 | 
| 461 | NES     | atlantis.png                   | 
| 469 | NES     | dragow.png                     | 
| 476 | NES     | mm5.png                        | 
| 499 | NES     | RushNatack.png                 | 
| 502 | NES     | princep.png                    | 
| 503 | NES     | deadlytowers.png               | 
| 510 | NES     | smb2phil.png                   | 
| 529 | NES     | mermaid.png                    | 
| 532 | NES     | flintstones.png                | 
| 545 | NES     | mm4.png                        | 
| 555 | NES     | sturricanz.png                 | 
| 562 | NES     | ninjagai1_v2.png               | 
| 563 | NES     | spelunk.png                    | 
| 565 | NES     | mm6a.png                       | 
| 571 | NES     | tmnt2.png                      | 
| 579 | NES     | gimmick.png                    | 
| 596 | NES     | krion.png                      | 
| 699 | NES     | dtaleso.png                    | 
| 726 | NES     | megaman_v8.png                 | 
| 734 | NES     | zanac.png                      | 
| 741 | NES     | mm2sb.png                      | 
| 744 | NES     | nightshd.png                   | 
| 756 | NES     | contrapacifist.png             | 
| 766 | NES     | mtpo.png                       | 
| 771 | NES     | guerillawar.png                | 
| 774 | NES     | jaws1.png                      | 
| 775 | NES     | circus.png                     | 
| 824 | NES     | altppglitch.png                | 
| 828 | NES     | ninjagaiden2b.png              | 
| 853 | NES     | ghostsng2.png                  | 
| 855 | NES     | donkjr.png                     | 
| 873 | NES     | lolo7.png                      | 
| 883 | NES     | rootbeerrocket.png             | 
| 899 | NES     | kydicarus.png                  | 
| 900 | NES     | ralstice.png                   | 
| 918 | NES     | chipdale2.png                  | 
| 930 | NES     | uninvited.png                  | 
| 932 | NES     | shgate.png                     | 
| 940 | NES     | lolo2rh.png                    | 
| 961 | NES     | arkanoid.png                   | 
| 441 | SNES    | tattack.png                    | 
| 522 | SNES    | dkcfull.png                    | 
| 690 | SNES    | umiharashort.png               | 
| 706 | SNES    | ffmqd.png                      | 
| 859 | SNES    | illugaia.png                   | 
| 870 | SNES    | hook.png                       | 
| 872 | SNES    | aladdin.png                    | 
| 894 | SNES    | simpsonsbn.png                 | 
| 895 | SNES    | nosferatu.png                  | 
| 904 | SNES    | bskaizou2.png                  | 
| 911 | SNES    | magicalquestmickeymouse_v2.png | 
| 934 | SNES    | mk2quirks.jpg                  | 
+-----+---------+--------------------------------+
86 rows in set (0.01 sec)
Skilled player (1399)
Joined: 5/31/2004
Posts: 1821
Bisqwit: Does that list mention the same files, or only with the same file name? I thought the instructions mentioned that the most practical way of renewing a screenshot was to keep the same filename... at he full arkanoid movie for instance, there is a new screenshot (although it has the same filename).
JXQ
Experienced player (749)
Joined: 5/6/2005
Posts: 3132
Ah, so that's why the Arkanoid screenshot is the same as before. I think that keeping the same name on a new screenshot (and thus erasing the old screenshot) is a bad idea because obsolete movies are still accessible on the site and should have a unique screenshot associated with them, just like non-obsoleted movies. Thoughts?
<Swordless> Go hug a tree, you vegetarian (I bet you really are one)
Senior Moderator
Joined: 8/4/2005
Posts: 5769
Location: Away
I agree.
Warp wrote:
Edit: I think I understand now: It's my avatar, isn't it? It makes me look angry.
Active player, Editor (296)
Joined: 3/8/2004
Posts: 7468
Location: Arzareth
JXQ wrote:
I think that keeping the same name on a new screenshot (and thus erasing the old screenshot) is a bad idea because obsolete movies are still accessible on the site and should have a unique screenshot associated with them, just like non-obsoleted movies.
You're right about that. I used to think that using the old one is okay when there is no significant change, i.e. the new screenshot can apply to both.
JXQ
Experienced player (749)
Joined: 5/6/2005
Posts: 3132
Alright, I'm going to start on this list. Since it would take forever to put each screenshot here for a consensus, I'm just going to pick them myself. Any screenshot that someone isn't happy with, post about it here and those ones can be discussed more.
<Swordless> Go hug a tree, you vegetarian (I bet you really are one)
Joined: 8/13/2005
Posts: 356
Location: Canada
I went through yesterday and made a list of screenshots that I thought could be improved. I don't necessarily have suggestions for each because I wasn't watching the movies at the time, but I recall these runs being relatively interesting and the screenshots are pretty boring. In some cases it might just be that I'm missing whatever trick/shortcut/injoke makes them clever. EDIT: Edited in suggestions for Final Fantasy Adventure. I'll continue if it's helpful. EDIT: Removed the ones that were updated and put in a couple more suggestions. EDIT AGAIN: Most of those ones I suggested above were changed in November 2007, and I'm just adding this in because otherwise this post would be a confusing relic.
Joined: 5/13/2006
Posts: 283
FreshFeeling wrote:
  • 815: GBA "100%" Metroid Fusion (USA) by BioSpark
That would be the result of a scrolling glitch; normally you would never see anywhere near as much of the door as you see there.
<Zurreco> if so called professional players cant adapt to every playing field, theyre obviously not that great
Editor, Skilled player (1936)
Joined: 6/15/2005
Posts: 3239
Updated screenshots for Mega Man 1, 2, 4, 6.
Active player (421)
Joined: 9/27/2004
Posts: 650
Location: Canada
FreshFeeling wrote:
  • 781: NES Legend of Zelda 2 (USA) by Rising Tempest & Inzult
I actually think this screenshot reasonably demonstrates the spirit of the run. I think it's kind of funny. You know, since approximately 95% of the run is walking through town. But this moment might be a suitable replacement. I can't look at the exact frame number, as my desktop is (once again) out of comission, and I'm (once again) rockin' my iBook.
JXQ
Experienced player (749)
Joined: 5/6/2005
Posts: 3132
FreshFeeling, thanks for the suggestions. I'll look at them once I get this initial list down to a reasonable size. And yes, frame suggestions are welcome to any run. (Especially helpful on a game like Final Fantasy Adventure which I know nothing about) FractalFusion, thank you! I especially like your choice for MM6 :)
<Swordless> Go hug a tree, you vegetarian (I bet you really are one)
Editor, Skilled player (1936)
Joined: 6/15/2005
Posts: 3239
BS Kaizou Choujin and Mega Man II updated. JXQ, you beat me to Solstice. This was going to be my screenshot:
JXQ
Experienced player (749)
Joined: 5/6/2005
Posts: 3132
Fractal, wow, I had to look twice before I found a difference :) Of the ones I did recently, two that I'm not so sure on are Gimmick! and Super Mario Bros. 2. (The one I really liked from Gimmick! turned out to be from the same room that the any% screenshot is from. My rationale for the current one is that it was from the extra level and it had several goofy characters in one screen.) SMB2 is a pretty popular movie here, so if anyone has a suggestion they prefer, that would be great. Here's the other choice I was debating on for it: Edit: I ended up using this area for a screenshot to the newest any% movie.
<Swordless> Go hug a tree, you vegetarian (I bet you really are one)
Active player, Editor (465)
Joined: 5/23/2006
Posts: 361
Location: Washington, United States
Could you change the screenshot for Link's Awakening DX? I'm not exactly sure what significance the current screenshot has (it's just a text box, after all... I think it could be changed to something more representative of how glitchy the movie is). What about one of these:
Chef Stef wrote:
A few more screenshot ideas: Frame 144264 Frame 199624
Experienced player (821)
Joined: 11/18/2006
Posts: 2426
Location: Back where I belong
Excellent progress so far JXQ, I just checked my spiderman movie and find the new shot much improved.
Living Well Is The Best Revenge My Personal Page
Post subject: Re: General screenshot discussion for publications
Player (209)
Joined: 2/18/2005
Posts: 1451
JXQ wrote:
Phase 2: General updating suggestions SNES Secret of Evermore
I think this is a good idea, as the current screenshot is in a too dark location which is hard to recognize. The best screenshot suggestion I coud think of would be this one: Alternatively I think Horace's Camp characterizes the game very well too:
See my perfect 100% movie-walkthroughs of the best RPG games on http://www.freewebs.com/saturnsmovies/index.htm Current TAS project (with new videos): Super Metroid Redesign, any% speedrun