The run was alo streamed with commentary by Lord Tom, Tompa and the console record holder Kirua: http://www.twitch.tv/tompa/c/6541750
This is technically an improvement of one of the oldest TASes on the site: [15] NES Super Mario Bros. 3 "all levels" by Tokushin in 1:17:40.70. Though that one does not beat all HB's (skips the secret one in W2), starts and finishes all levels as Small Mario, always gets three star cards at the end of the level and is done on the much slower Japanese version.
This TAS aims for 100% completion of Super Mario Bros. 3, as defined by:
1. All regular levels entered and completed
2. All World-Map Hammer Brother and Pirahna Plant levels completed
3. All World-8 Auto-Scrollers and Hand levels completed
In practice, this means we play every level skipped in the Warpless run by using a Jugem's Cloud, RNG manipulation or simply walking around it.
For comparison, the realtime speedrun record for the same goal is currently 1:11:02.

Lord Tom's Comments

It's been quite a ride. We started working on this in 2013, doing simultaneous planning/testing for an improvement to the Warpless run. Progress came in fits and starts, with Tompa TAS'ing most of the levels first and me trying to improve them. Progress stalled, but in a good way, about a year ago with the discovery of the game-end glitch which ultimately led to an entirely new TAS in its own category.
Major props go to Tompa for managing to stay motivated over such a long period of time, cranking out and optimizing relentlessly.
Overall, I'm very happy with the quality of this run, both in terms of macro and micro optimizations. Aesthetically, I slightly regret that even a 100% will still include in-level skips that let Mario avoid the meat of certain cool levels (e.g. non-game-end-glitched 7-1). But it was difficult to envision how to non-aribtrarily justify that goal-wise absent a "no major glitches" run which didn't really interest me.
At times I got a bit burnt out on this game the past two years, but much less so recently -- good thing, since I have 2 more SMB3 submissions in the works for after we get the Warpless in! Enjoy!

Tompa's Comments

Another fun SMB3 run to work on! Despite TASing this game several times, there are still new things to find, new ways to optimise and it's just as enjoyable to work on as ever before.
Working with Lord Tom is always great. It's nice to have someone to point out my silly mistakes. He also does a good job looking into the game's code to figure out a couple of things. Something I'm personally pretty bad at...
And there is still the new Warpless TAS we have yet to finish. I should stop writing this and get back to work!

New and Newish Strats (In descending order of approximate time saved)

Wall-Jump Wand Grab

Discovered by GlitchMan, this strat involves Mario using a wall jump at the end of Airship boss battles to get on top of the right-hand wall and then jump back to the left to grab the wand from mid-air. It's not possible to stand on top of the left-hand wall. Crucially, the wand is grabbed above the top of the screen, which saves a few seconds of animation time, both of the wand falling and later of Mario falling to enter the King's room.
The major optimization we discovered by reviewing the game's source code is that the boss's shell actually follows a computed trajectory when it flies offscreen; at the end of this trajectory, the shell changes into a wand, which then falls down toward Mario. This trajectory is computed according to a somewhat hackish formula; the best trajectories are those where the boss-wand transformation takes place as close to the ground as possible. Generally, having the boss closer to the middle of the screen is better, but the strange formula used means that some boss positions may be unexpectedly good (or bad).

Ducking into Water

When Mario runs off a ledge that is just underwater, he can preserve x speed by ducking just as he falls off the ledge. This trick has apparently been known for some time in the realtime speedrunning community, and saves quite a chunk of frames due to Mario's pitiful swimming skills.

Power-ups from the Map Hammer Brothers

Fighting Hammer Brothers on certain World Map locations makes power-ups available from what would otherwise be ordinary blocks. This can be useful both in providing a leaf or flower not otherwise available, and because the 30 frame power-up animation can be avoided by grabbing the power-up just as the Hammer-fight sequence ends. This is used in World 1 to get a flower and in World 6 to get a leaf.

Running Through White Blocks

Mario normally stops moving when he grabs a white block from the side. We found that Mario could avoid getting stopped with the right x pixel value. This is useful in a few places, but most dramatically with the "Buzz-saw" in 6-5, where Mario grinds through an entire row of white blocks to avoid jumping (which impacts P-meter expiration when Mario has the racoon suit).

Hammer Triple-Team

In World 4, we discovered we could save a Map Hammer Brother's walking step (32 frames) by lining all 3 Hammers up in a row and fighting the middle one first. Afterward, the remaining two Hammers are manipulated to walk onto Mario at the same time, saving a turn of Hammer movement. I was kind of hoping based on the game's treatment of other situations that both Hammers would be killed with a single fight, but we still have to fight both. That's probably for the best in any case, as if only one fight occurred it would arguably violate the run's goals.

Lakitu

There are a few water levels where optimizing Lakitu's movement is useful. Within limits, Lakitu continuously accelerates toward the player. Therefore, we discovered, if you need Lakitu to go right as quickly as possible, the fastest way is to have Mario get to the right of Lakitu as quickly as possible -- even if that requires a path that otherwise would be slower for Mario moving right.

Water Corner Boost

Tompa discovered that various small boosts are possible while swimming. These are mainly used in World 3's 2nd fortress.

Air-Walk

This odd glitch was independently discovered by Producks and Lord Tom. On some auto-scrollers it is possible to invoke a glitch by pressing against the left side of the screen. When the glitch is activated, Mario's walking surface rises into the air, allowing him to (briefly) run and even jump/land in thin air. The pattern Mario's surface follows leads us to suspect that some value is being overwritten by a thrown wrench causing the glitch. Look for usage of this glitch in the World 7 Airship and the World 8 Ship.
The Air-Walk is listed last because it doesn't save ANY time, nor does it have any known or theoretical use apart from entertainment.

World/Level Comments

World 1

1-4
The first autoscroller, get used to these... Getting the leaf will save time on the fort as well as showing off some swag with the shell!
1-F
When you start flying, a 256 frame counter will start. We delay the start of the flight by slowing down to lose the full P-meter. The same method is used in 2-3 as well.
1-HB
In order for the chest to spawn, the Hammer Brother as well as his projectiles need to be off screen. Jumping on a HB will have him drop down quicker than hitting from below or kill with a fire ball. For this fight, it was possible to manipulate it to not throw the hammer, this ended up being three frames slower.
1-5
We pressed down in the slope to have Mario's speed instantly drop to 0, in order to jump over the wall as quickly as possible.
1-6
Because of Fire Mario, a much quicker P-speed is possible, it's very precise!
1-Airship
The invisible block/bouncing flower glitch is done by hitting the block so that the item appears on the same frame the cannon spins. Clipping into the wall will have Mario scroll further to the right than the camera normally allows. This is used in most of the autoscrollers, though not always possible.

World 2

2-F
New strategy by Glitchman and the first use of a P-wing!
2-3
Thanks to having the leaf we can fly up and hit the P-switch. We can keep the P-speed by getting hit while flying and then simply fall through the block and into the pipe. Very convenient.
2-Pyramid
This one is hard to optimise because of the slopes and the lag you get when destroying the blocks. Sadly, all the lag can't be avoided.

World 3

3-1
Small mistake here, which didn't actually waste any time in the end. After the P-speed up, it's faster to land on the block and walk for a few frames. Mario's speed is accelerating quicker when walking under water rather than swimming. When redoing the level later on, saving time gave us a bad pattern for the Hammer Brothers. So no time was actually lost.
3-2
With careful use of the fireballs and when to kill the fish, you can despawn the flower in the end without getting any lag or waste any time. The lag-free method wasn't found until later. And again, because of the Hammer Brothers, it wasn't faster to despawn the flower anyway. No time lost here either!
3-5
Some nice walljumping clears this level quickly, no one likes swimming anyway.
3-7
A lot of lag reduction in this level. It's also the main reason why the higher route is taken, despite being able to kill a lot more enemies and being able to get more corner boosts.
3-F2
The only level in the run where having a Frog Suit would save time. Getting the suit is a huge timewaster though, as you have to enter a Toad House to get it (Or a long detour in 3-9...). Clipping into the ? block gives both a boost from the block itself, but also increases the speed for a short time as there is no water behind the block.
3-8
If you land directly into the water, your speed will drop down to 0. Luckily, there are a couple of blocks that you can land on first. If you then make a duck-jump, the P-speed will be kept while swimming and the P-meter intact. This ended up saving a lot of time compared to the current Warpless TAS.
3-9
The 256-frame counter for the P-speed will also counting down while jumping. If you land on solid ground before it reaches 0, it will reset and start counting down again the next time you jump. This is also useful when going down/up pipes, as the P-meter won't disappear while swimming, we reach the last part of the level without ever losing the P-meter in the level.

World 4

4-2
An ever faster method was used to get P-speed early.
4-4
For some reason, jumping in midair can't be done if you finished a Fort in the level before... Jumping out of the water is slower in terms of Mario's speed and position, though it makes Lakitu turn around quicker to earlier jump up on the platform. Then careful position and speed optimisation made it possible to jump on Lakitu without getting hit by the spiny.
4-HBs
Having two HBs move onto Mario at the same time, saves one map movement, 32 frames. Triple Kill!
4-6
A lot of lag at the later part of the level. Having Fire lets us reduce some of it. We lost a real-time frame to reduce a frame of lag. Because the RNG address is paused during lag, this was a better option in this case. As it means less frames delayed for W5 HBs.
4-F2
Another instant where a faster strategy could have been used though not faster because of RNG... It's quicker to land on the dry bones and jump all the way to the highest platform, without using the brick. "Thanks to" HB movement, no time lost.
4-Airship
Nintendo were very evil to reduce the scrolling speed to 1 pixel every 4 frames compared to to 1 every 2 frames.

World 5

5-1
As we need to fight all the Hammer Brothers anyway, getting the Music Box in this level is not faster.
5-2
Walljumps are great <3. Ducking under the paratroopa to avoid getting hit is quite precise.
5-3
RNG is yet again evil and won't let us save as much as we wished for. Faster P-speed strategy is possible however. While the shoe is awesome, it has no use in this run. Deepest apologies.
5-Tower
Going down a pipe on the side is only possible from the right. If the pipe would take you to a lower section of the level (Like in 3-9 and 5-3) Mario will be falling from the very top of the level and will take several minutes before dropping down. This ends up making this pipe the only one in the game where time could be saved for this category.
5-4
A boost from the spinner increases Mario's speed from 56 to 64. To keep the speed we have to land on specific frames and jump as soon as possible. WHen you jump on the first frame you land, the 256 frame counter for your P-meter will continue to drop down. It's therefore impossible to keep speed 64 and the P-meter through the whole level.
5-6
Feeling hungry? Better order a pizza!
A few frames were delayed to not get crushed by the camera when entering the pipe. Also why getting ahead of the camera with clipping is not used.
5-7
Thanks to Fire Mario, early P-speed is obtained without the use of a star.
5-9
The pizza arrived! Munch munch munch!
A lot of effort was put into getting P-speed during the level, which would have saved time at the last part. While being close, it ended up not being possible.

World 6

6-3
Tricky to get P-speed early. Though it worked out fairly well.
6-F1
The second P-wing used in the run and the first time since World 2 we aren't Fire Mario! Killing Boom Boom with a star is very satisfying.
6-6
Clever strategy by GlitchMan! Skips a water level section with a tricky P-meter maneuver.
6-5
Obtaining the Leaf in the HB fight was first forgotten about. Thanks to Kirua for reminding us, the levels were redone and a lot of time was saved with a new strategy! Explained in the Starts section above.
6-F2
While having the Leaf already, using a third P-wing was faster. As the P-meter won't run out. You want to fly as little as possible and only jump on certain frames, to avoid losing too much speed in the process.
6-8
Keeping the leaf helps us reduce lag as well as filling up the P-meter quicker.
6-9
Another water section we don't want to play. Walljumping is here to save the day once again.
6-10
Getting through the big wall took a lot of thinking and redoing. One of the problems is that with low speed, we have to jump on the first frame we land in order to not lose the P-meter. Welcome back, Fire Mario!
6-Airship
Lemmy is dumb. Mario has to jump to hit him on his head with the fire. Then just jump on either him or one of his balls (!) to get up on the top.

World 7

7-1
Warping to the credits? Haha, good one, that's clearly impossible.
7-2
The white block was used to kill the Piranha Plant. As the Fire Balls move slower than Mario does with P-speed, the blocks helps killing the flower without wasting time.
7-5
Originally the top route was used to finish this level. Going up and down the pipes is very slow however. Lord Tom came up with using the P-wing instead, this ended up several seconds with lots of wallclips!
7-4
This level was one of the first thing we discussed for this TAS. Tompa came up with the idea of clipping through the top in order to skip this water, auto-scroller. He never believed it possible. Then Lord Tom, after lots of testing managed to get it with the Leaf and later on with the P-wing. This is probably the most precise thing in the run. Your speed, position, x and y subpixels as well as the speed frame rule, all have to cooperate for perfection. The result is very satisfying.
-Piranha Plant 1
Mario felt suicidal and jumped into a pipe to do so. As soon as the item from the chest stops blinking, no time will be lost by going through the pipe and despite dying (Fake death, no lives lost!) the level is still cleared.
7-F1
Using the P-wing was a few frames faster than keeping the leaf from a non-fake-death in the previous stage. Our last P-wing is gone!
7-8
One of the two (Second being Bowser's Castle) levels where using a star is faster. There is a hidden Hammer Suit here. It didn't end up being useful. Main reason is that the koopakids can't be killed using the Hammer + the long time it takes to get the suit. In total, about six seconds slower.
7-9
One more frame had to be saved before the first wallclip, which we couldn't do. The reason is the framerule for the speed and the P-meter. Which is why we slow down before each wallclip.
7-F2
Another level where going down on the side of the pipe could be faster. Here Mario would have gone down into the lava and died instead... It was close to get through both the dry bones and the waffle-ball without taking damage, though only possible with the P-wing and that is slower.
7-Airship
First use of the Air-walk glitch explained above. While not useful, it's still nice to see something new in these auto-scrollers.

World 8

8-Tank 1
Not having the leaf really shows how few 1ups you are able to get... Some lives could be obtained, but to the cost of lag frames. In the end it wouldn't help us get 99 lives anyway, so saving time was put as a priority for these autoscrollers.
8-Hand 1
Even if you want to do all these levels, getting the hand animation has to be avoided to save time, this is done by simply delaying when to enter the level. By quickly ducking under the fireballs, the P-meter can be filled up quickly without getting hit. The rest is cake!
8-1, 8-2 and 8-F
These three are already quite optimised from previous SMB3 runs. With a lot of testing, Mario could end up be about a pixel ahead at some points. Though it was never enough to save a full frame.
Bowser's Castle
As with the any% no game end glitch run, frames had to be delayed to manipulate Bowser's pattern, 21 frames again to be exact.

Thanks

GlitchMan - his WIP of a warpless improvement through 2-F introduced some useful strats, most notably the "Wall-Jump" Airship strat used for all Airship bosses and which saves many seconds. He also posted useful strats on certain later levels, notably 5-1 and 6-6.
Kirua - for helpful suggestions including getting the leaf from a World 6 hammer brother and generally being great.
The rest of the SMB3 speedrun community for continues support and sharing ideas.

Noxxa: Pending acception Judging.

Tompa: Replaced movie because of a subtitle error. Nothing else altered.
Noxxa: Great run with a lot of nice tricks. Accepting for Moons. I did consider this run for a Star, but the run does not look like it significantly outweighs the entertainment value of the similar warpless run, so I won't accept it for a tier higher than that yet. The star-worthiness of either run may still be discussed, but I'm not seeing enough support at the moment (and some opposition as well). So, Moons it is.
Spikestuff: Reach for the sta- Moon.


Samsara
She/They
Senior Judge, Site Admin, Expert player (2240)
Joined: 11/13/2006
Posts: 2822
Location: Northern California
Getting 99 lives has been in almost every SMB3 TAS for nearly 10 years. You can pretty much literally look at any other published or obsoleted SMB3 run if you want to see Mario slowly floating between cannon shots to make a number go up. It wasn't all that entertaining even back when it was novel, and it's only gotten more and more uninteresting over the years.
TASvideos Admin and acting Senior Judge 💙 Currently unable to dedicate a lot of time to the site, taking care of family. Now infrequently posting on Bluesky
warmCabin wrote:
You shouldn't need a degree in computer science to get into this hobby.
Lord_Tom
He/Him
Expert player (3145)
Joined: 5/25/2007
Posts: 399
Location: New England
adelikat wrote:
This run has some amazing moments, all of which will also be in a warpless improvement. This movie validates the original reasoning of doing warpless as opposed to 100%. The vast majority of the content added by this category are levels where the authors struggle to provide entertaining content (and give up and order a pizza <_<). This is a cool run, I enjoyed it, and we can publish it. But I think the warpless is more entertaining overall, and a better category choice, obsoleting it would be a bummer.
I think it's a stretch to say all of the amazing moments will also be in the warpless, and disagree that the new content is where we struggled to provide entertainment. Everyone can have their own opinions about what the best parts of a run are, but for me a lot of the best parts of the 100% (1-4, 2-3, World 4 hammer brother triple-team, death-without-dying in World 7 Pirahna level) won't be in the warpless. The biggest struggles to provide entertainment (from my perspective) were the Auto-scrollers that are also in the warpless which have been done many times and aren't very variable; some of the World 1-7 non-airship auto's are better than others, but overall they provide more variety than among the airships and world 8 auto's IMO. The 99-life issue is valid discussion IMO; but for me the thrill about it is getting to 99 in a short run like the any %. In general we tried to be as fast and entertaining as possible everywhere we could, it was a design decision but we just didn't prioritize the lives issue. I agree that this run shouldn't obsolete the warpless, else we'd feel pretty silly separately improving the warpless. :)
Soig
He/Him
Skilled player (1518)
Joined: 12/4/2010
Posts: 252
Cool job! I'm so interested in this run. So reply here firstly and then watch it EDIT: Big YES vote! Funny walkthrough and high skills! Mario can crab the wand even without flying. Somewhere getting P-speed is faster than published record.
Ford
He/Him
Joined: 3/5/2013
Posts: 183
Location: California
That was an entertaining way for me to spend my early evening.
Experienced player (702)
Joined: 2/19/2006
Posts: 742
Location: Quincy, MA
I'm honestly surprised people care about 99 lives. It's like the least important thing. Why does a TAS need extra lives!? I mean, seriously? Couldn't you guys have gotten 99 lives by getting the leaf in 1-4 as early as possible?
Super Mario Bros. console speedrunner - Andrew Gardikis
Tompa
Any
Editor, Expert player (2224)
Joined: 8/15/2005
Posts: 1943
Location: Mullsjö, Sweden
We could certainly have recieved a few more lives, yes. But it wouldn't have been enough for 99 lives anyway. And to be honest, I don't care either =P.
Editor, Skilled player (1441)
Joined: 3/31/2010
Posts: 2112
If ya couldn't have done 99, you shoulda at least gone for some funny number like 42 or 69. But 78, what significance does 78 bear? It's not even a prime number!
Spikestuff
They/Them
Editor, Publisher, Expert player (2655)
Joined: 10/12/2011
Posts: 6446
Location: The land down under.
78 Sphenic, Abundant, Erdos–Woods, Semiperfect and the 12th Triangular number.
WebNations/Sabih wrote:
+fsvgm777 never censoring anything.
Disables Comments and Ratings for the YouTube account. Something better for yourself and also others.
Skilled player (1742)
Joined: 9/17/2009
Posts: 4986
Location: ̶C̶a̶n̶a̶d̶a̶ "Kanatah"
Joined: 9/22/2014
Posts: 33
Location: New Taipei City, Taiwan
Wow! The tricks for each castle are amazing! Yes vote.
DennisBalow
He/Him
Former player
Joined: 1/23/2010
Posts: 27
Location: Germany
Incredible and the text makes stuff often clearly and understand better what's going on, or why you do something, i have played the game only casual, so i it was kind of useful. Yes vote couldn't spend my time any better.
Asdrien
He/Him
Player (141)
Joined: 11/17/2014
Posts: 27
Location: France
Amazing !! Yes vote.
Player (71)
Joined: 8/24/2004
Posts: 2562
Location: Sweden
That was a very nice run to watch! Big yes vote!
Post subject: Movie published
TASVideoAgent
They/Them
Moderator
Joined: 8/3/2004
Posts: 15619
Location: 127.0.0.1
This movie has been published. The posts before this message apply to the submission, and posts after this message apply to the published movie. ---- [2835] NES Super Mario Bros. 3 "all levels" by Lord_Tom & Tompa in 1:04:36.90
Skilled player (1742)
Joined: 9/17/2009
Posts: 4986
Location: ̶C̶a̶n̶a̶d̶a̶ "Kanatah"
Wait, there was a 100% TAS of this submitted way back? TIL. :P
Noxxa
They/Them
Moderator, Expert player (4128)
Joined: 8/14/2009
Posts: 4090
Location: The Netherlands
jlun2 wrote:
Wait, there was a 100% TAS of this submitted way back? TIL. :P
"Submitted" isn't exactly the right word. Look at the date and description of the old publication in question. For the record, that run used to be marked as obsoleted by the 2006 "warpless" run, but this was changed around because that run has the same goals as this run. It makes more sense this way.
http://www.youtube.com/Noxxa <dwangoAC> This is a TAS (...). Not suitable for all audiences. May cause undesirable side-effects. May contain emulator abuse. Emulator may be abusive. This product contains glitches known to the state of California to cause egg defects. <Masterjun> I'm just a guy arranging bits in a sequence which could potentially amuse other people looking at these bits <adelikat> In Oregon Trail, I sacrificed my own family to save time. In Star trek, I killed helpless comrades in escape pods to save time. Here, I kill my allies to save time. I think I need help.
Joined: 2/21/2008
Posts: 255
13 minute improvement and commentary? Can I still vote yes? If not, too bad, I'm still voting yes.
"The guy was fatally injured and wants to be covered by God's tears (rain) before he dies. God is too busy to bother because it wastes frames." Frames 16:26
Zakatos
He/Him
Joined: 7/26/2004
Posts: 90
Location: Brazil, Sao Paulo, Campinas
Taking the Frog Suit at World 3 Mushroom House isn't worth for a faster 4-4 completion?
The eyes of a machine are wonderful, but there's nothing like the the eyes of the heart – Old Cid, Cybercop
Lord_Tom
He/Him
Expert player (3145)
Joined: 5/25/2007
Posts: 399
Location: New England
No, actually I believe (Tompa will know for sure) that 4-4 would be slower with the frog suit even if no time was spent getting it. The reason is while the Frog suit swims "fast" compared to other Mario suits, the fastest Frog swimming speed (2 px/frame) is quite slow compared to max running speed (3.5 px/frame), and is even slower than non-P-speed running (2.5 px/frame). And although acceleration is very slow, regular Mario's max swim speed isn't all that much slower at 1.5 px/frame. With the variety of tricks available to minimize the time spent regular swimming, it's almost always faster to use a non-Frog suit and stick near the surface. The exception is the 2nd fortress in World 3, the lone level where significant deep-underwater swimming seems to be unavoidable. Even in that case, however, it saves less than the time required to get and equip a frog suit, which is about 10 seconds.
Joined: 1/13/2007
Posts: 343
Too late to vote no because 1) Doesn't complete a treasure ship 2) doesn't collect all white mushroom houses (you can't call it 100% if it doesn't get those...) 3) doesn't flip the mushroom house panels (yes I know it requires no skill, eats time and is not entertaining, but if they can be flipped, they must in my opinion. and you can manipulate items from them to help you) 4) doesn't collect the spade panels (each one is 5 lives, so should be able to get to 99 that way. Again, those are panels not flipped...) 5) doesn't complete an n-spade panel (really only need to insist on one of those) 6) doesn't beat an airship with any of the special suits, much less all three. (these give you unique messages from the king, and are thus skipped content.) 7) doesn't collect all the big ? blocks. 8) doesn't show off the 3 of a kind animations. 9) doesn't use kuriboh's shoe. :) This only qualifies as "all levels" in my opinion. :) I'm well aware that many of these cost time, and many don't really show that much skill, but many of them can in theory save time elsewhere by making more map powerups available, which would be more entertaining.
Editor, Skilled player (1824)
Joined: 8/25/2013
Posts: 1200
100% doesn't mean doing arbitrary crap just because, you know.
effort on the first draft means less effort on any draft thereafter - some loser
Joined: 1/13/2007
Posts: 343
I admit i was laying it on a bit thick, but my point was that for a 100%, there was sure a lot of stuff skipped. :)
BigBoct
He/Him
Editor, Former player
Joined: 8/9/2007
Posts: 1692
Location: Tiffin/Republic, OH
I'm curious, how much time is it to enter a Toad house as compared to how much time would be saved with a Frog Suit for 3-F2? Because if memory serves, the Toad House in the secret part of World 2 is a guaranteed Frog Suit, and it's right on the way.
Previous Name: boct1584
Lord_Tom
He/Him
Expert player (3145)
Joined: 5/25/2007
Posts: 399
Location: New England
boct1584 wrote:
I'm curious, how much time is it to enter a Toad house as compared to how much time would be saved with a Frog Suit for 3-F2? Because if memory serves, the Toad House in the secret part of World 2 is a guaranteed Frog Suit, and it's right on the way.
IIRC it's about 10 seconds to go to a Toad house. Add another second or so to equip the Frog suit, and (on average) another second to get Fire back afterward, and another few seconds for the slower boss fight - call it 15 seconds. Tompa did the timing on this, so I don't know the exact #, but as I recall it wasn't really close for 3-F2. The frog suit seems much faster in water than it actually turns out to be, I think this is because it can change directions instantly at full speed. Fast swimming with the frog suit gives speed 32 (2 px/frame). Non-frog max swimming speed is 24 (1.5 px/frame). So ignoring the need to accelerate, the frog only swims 33% faster, which isn't going to get you in the ballpark of saving 15 seconds.
Tompa
Any
Editor, Expert player (2224)
Joined: 8/15/2005
Posts: 1943
Location: Mullsjö, Sweden
With Fire: Enter the castle -> full black screen after finishing: 2259 With Frog: B to equip the Frog Suit -> full black screen after finishing: 2197 (Includes taking damage to lose the Frog Suit). Afterwards, you'll lose quite a lot of time due to not having the Fire Flower. It is possible to get back the Fire Flower in both 3-8 and 3-9, but it's very slow in both cases (I have not timed them). For 3-8: You won't be able to get P-speed as early, because the Koopa is in the way. If you get the Fire, you won't be able to built up P-speed either, without backtracking to build up the speed. Losing many seconds in both scenarios. It's also seconds lost in 3-9 if you get the Flower back there. There's no Flower in the Airship, meaning huge time loss against Wendy, as well as some in 4-1, 4-2, until you get another shot at wasting seconds to regain it in 4-Fort... etc. So yeah, while 3-F2 itself will be 62 frames faster, it will be at a cost of way too much =).