With the help of
this lua script nitsuja wrote to remove boring things like special stages, score tally, and the super sonic music, I have finally watched this (with the great help of . While there are a few route choices I'm unsure of (mostly having to do with the collection of giant rings), the quality of play is certainly up to site standards.
Furthemore, collection of all emeralds, and lack of tails certainly distinguishes it from the currently published sonic run, and sonic's moveset and level differences significantly differentiate it from the published all emeralds knuckles run.
The goal choice is not arbitrary, it limits him to the set of tricks that was used in SprintGod's widely lauded S3K TAS (with three exceptions, two of which are each only applicable to a single level).
Stylistically, it's a little bit lackluster, but hardly to the point that it should impede publication (as my own past submissions demonstrate).
I see no compelling reason not to vote yes.