Recently, there has been discussion regarding the entertainment and technical merit of submissions, and whether each requirement should be relaxed in order to increase game diversity and to encourage newbie retention (respectively). In an attempt to better myself as a judge, and to provide some clarification on the thought process that I use when judging, I have created a rubric to help better define my opinions. It is located at my homepage
http://tasvideos.org/Mmbossman.html
under "Judging Rubric". I would like to hear opinions on the ideas located within.
Also, please don't turn this thread into one which argues the validity of the rating system (including whether or not you can measure technical achievement). I've already voiced my opinions on those topics elsewhere, and I may be prompted to expand on them further if needed, but I'd rather stick to current content for now.
So, what do people think?
