I agree that there should be some degree of curation or moderation at least. Just I do not think it needs to be a process that blocks a submission from being on the site. Or even that everything needs to be curated. Like if we have playground type stuff that could just be there on its own like SFII single fight playarounds for example. Just need to be upfront with what the movie is, and where it is in the process with all flags set (whatever we could decide they are). About publication...honestly I would be fine if people just linked their own youtube videos on it.
Here is an idea for a process.
- Submission. User selects game and game region. Video link inclusion possibly required.
- Verify correct game. Submission goes to temporary area where a judge would verify it is the right game. But NOT check goal and sync at this point.
- Set flags. Set "to be curated", "video not verified" "sync not checked" "goal not verified" and then it would be archived to the correct game.
- Judge checks Sync OR Goal. Judges can select which ones to check goal or sync.
- After either of those are done then mark that flag.
- When both are complete the rest of the flags like fastest completion could be set if it satisfies those criteria if someone wishes.
- Publication.
----------------------
Publication has had some ideas. Publication needs to be manageable and I am not sure what that would look like. However personally I would advocate for something that is not so dependent on staff to get a more streamlined approach.
Publication process ideas summary abbreviation. Think I got the gist of the ideas here.
- Include Alternate tasvideos channel where the submitter or other community member provides the encode. main channel could host for example the fastest character "any%"
- Be more restrictive on what could be published so publishers can handle the workload. Such as only publishing "Staff picks".
- Still have publishers continue to try to publish everything
Feature Ideas to assist publication
- Streamlined tools to help with publication for members.
- Youtube integration for scheduling publication