About diversity. I can agree with that right now, there's too much of similar stuff in there.
RTS/RPG. I suggest one of these:
[1297] SNES EarthBound by pirohiko in 1:10:00.95
[2592] SNES Chrono Trigger by keylie in 2:17:08.86
Each of them has better rating than Warcraft, so we should consider that factor.
Also, we should pick one FPS, probably not necessarily Doom, ratings would help as well.
Regarding Fightings, see this:
http://tasvideos.org/Movies-C9010Y-RatingE.html
I'd add one of those too.
About current runs.
- SMB walkathon does feel like it's the weakest one indeed.
- SMB3 "warps" is so traditional it's probably not revolutionary anymore.
- Super Metroid "RBO" is a tough one, I'd say it's really really good, see the first page of this thread for the reasons.
- SM64 "0 star" - yeah, probably, same as SMB3 "warps".
- Majora's Mask - if we drop SM64, we'd need at least one 3D platform there.
- Mega Man 2 - traditionally cool run, quite obvious what it has to offer, but I would personally prefer Minus Infinity. Because it has glitches, it has planning, it has weapon management and stuff. Or maybe MM1, its techniques have been there for quite a while, so it won't look so absurd anymore I guess, like it did back when it was done. Or MMX "threesome".
- Sonic 3 - well, yeah, same thing over and over, even though it's a great game and a nice branch, but it seems to have too many weak spots.
- SMB3 "ACE" - NO FUCKING DOUBT! This has nothing to do with Mario, it's a Total Control thing, there's no way it is replaced with anything other. Pi? LOL, Pi is not even close to that level.
- Gradius - unsure anymore. I'd drop it if we really need the vacant place.
- Gimmick! - alright, we can keep it.
- The first 5 Samsara mentioned - No doubt either.