The Legend of Zelda "Swordless" (1st Quest)

  • aims for fastest time
  • takes damage to save time
  • abuses programming errors
  • manipulates luck
  • uses a game restart sequence
  • no deaths
  • no predefined saves
  • genre: adventure
  • uses emulator fceu 0.98.28
This run is my first submission to TASvideos and I believe the first of its kind.
This is one of my favorite all-time NES games. If you are unfamiliar with this game you can refer to Baxter and Morrison's 2nd quest movie submission notes for a brief recap of the plot here: #2091: Baxter & Morrison's NES The Legend of Zelda "2nd quest" in 24:59.83
You can also find a highly in-depth description of enemy drops, enemy movement, gameplay techniques, link's movement, and a description of the screen scroll glitch in those same submission notes.
This is technically not a "swordless" run for the obvious reason that you have to collect one of the three swords in order to hit Ganon and complete the game. There has been lots of discussion in the forums as to what the best way to end a run of this type would be. To my knowledge the point of this site is for people to show off game "completion" in the least amount of frames. Without collecting a sword, game completion is not possible. So instead of a freezing glitch, dying on Ganon, or stopping the movie when you enter Ganon's room, I chose to collect the sword and kill Ganon. Note that I only get the sword after acquiring all 8 peices of the triforce, and do not use it until the fight with Ganon.

A Few Quirks:

There are a few things I'd like to point out about my route, the screen scroll glitch, and enemy manipulations/drops.

Route:

First off, I was asked in the forums after I posted my WIP about why I use the gambling game more than the published 1st quest any %. In that run they only use the gambling game twice and get the rest of their rupees from enemy drops and a 100 rupee secret to everyone room on the way to level 8.
When I started attempting this run I noticed that if you get the candle on the way to level 4, when you pick up the ladder there and reset, the game for some unknown reason sets your item to the candle on restart. This of course is suboptimal since you don't need the candle until the 100 rupee secret room (if you plan on getting this) or level 8, and it forces you to access the menu to switch back to the bombs. After some testing I found that it is slightly faster to get the candle later (skipping the 100 rupees) since there's a candle room on the way to level 8. So basically you're trading 2 gamble screens for 1 menu screen and the 100 rupee secret, also allowing you to screen scroll glitch past the first candle room and the rupee secret. Furthermore, getting the candle near level 8 allows you to move up/right and down/left respectively, allowing a few frames to be saved by zig-zagging.
You may also wonder why I dont ever use the whistle to warp to level 3 to go to levels 4 and 7, and to level 1 when going to level 9. If going to level 7 before completing level 4 it is in fact faster to use the whistle, but with the screen scroll glitch it makes it optimal to do level 4 first and then over to level 7 by use of the glitch. Additionally I have to reset to get the wooden sword anyway, so I dont have to worry about walking 1 screen away from level 7 to use the whistle.
As for not using the whistle to go to level 1 after I pick up the wooden sword. In the any% they whistle from level 6 to 1, but I obviously have a different route and using the whistle after getting the wooden sword is much slower than just screen scroll glitch walking up past level 1.

Screen Scroll Glitch:

There are some places in the overworld where I do the glitch and I move in a seemingly suboptimal way. This only happens when moving north/south through the black portion at the top of the screen. For some reason if there's bushes or rocks at the top of the screen they are offset in some places by about a block worth of movement. For example, while on the way to get the 30 rupees in the beginning of the run, when screen scrolling at the first forest screen after the beach area, it looks like you may be able to hug the bushes on the right and perform the glitch there. This is not so because the bushes are offset slightly. This is the reason you see me enter the bottom of the screen in the middle, come out of the top half a block to the left, and have to go back to the right before i reenter from the top and move on. This happens a few times during the run and may look a bit strange.

Enemy Drops:

Some dungeon rooms again may seem suboptimal, and I'm sure a few frames could probably be saved here and there (although this would ultimately change the entire run from there on out which may or may not be desireable). You may see me kill some enemies first when it looked like i could have hit/killed more with the same bomb. Most of the time this is because i need to get a certain drop from a certain enemy and if I were to kill any other enemies first it would change the value of $052A thus changing the type of drop. An example of this would be in level 7 when entering the locked door room with 3 bats and 3 blue boomerang baddies, I drop 2 consecutive bombs to kill 2 of the 3 blue boomerangers where i could have killed some bats as well or even all 6 enemies with the 2 bombs. This is misleading because killing any of the bats before i killed the boomerangers would not have allowed me to get a bomb drop there. I tried to prevent this from happening as much as possible but unfortunately it does a few times.

Enemy Manipulations:

Since this is a swordless run it would seem unfair to compare dungeon room completion times to the any% runs. There is no sword present which makes it considerably harder to complete rooms in as timely a fashion (especially blue darknut rooms), because without the sword you can not do things like lay a bomb/swing your sword at the same time (possibly setting up enemies in a group) and swing your sword when the bomb explodes hitting them with both and doing extra damage (cutting down on enemy cooldown and bomb usage).

The Route:

As you can imagine the route plan for a swordless run is drastically different from an any% since you can only hit the dragon bosses of level 4 and 8 with the wand, and to get that you must get the ladder from level 4. With that in mind I believe that the route is pretty much fully optomized.
  • get 30 rupees from the friendly enemy
  • reset
  • get bombs
  • reset
  • use left over rupees for gambling
  • level 3 triforce
  • raft
  • save and continue
  • ladder
  • save and continue
  • bow
  • level 1 triforce
  • wand
  • level 6 triforce
  • reset
  • candle on the way to level 8
  • level 8 triforce
  • level 2 triforce
  • meat
  • whistle
  • level 5 triforce
  • reset
  • level 4 triforce
  • level 7 triforce
  • reset
  • wooden sword
  • reset
  • silver arrows
  • Ganon/Zelda

Credits:

I would like to thank Phil, Baxter, and Morrison for their 1st and 2nd quest any% runs and submission texts. Without these this run would never have been possible. And also Baxter again for his feedback and encouragement in pm's and the forums early on. A special thanks goes out to LordTom for responding to my posts recently. It seemed like people had lost interest in this run considering noone really responded to my posted WIP and additional comments. Your responses and encouragement were very timely, without which i may have put off finishing this run for awhile or possibly indefinately. I hope everyone enjoys the run whether published or not. Its been a long time coming!

adelikat: Claimined for judging. I think this submission has implications for the site as a whole so I will handle it. Expect a verdict in the upcoming days.

adelikat: Accepting for publication. Verdict

Aktan: Processing as "Swordless Challenge"

FractalFusion: Replaced movie to change rerecord count to 12000, which is closer to the number of actual rerecords done.

adelikat: Replace submission file with .fm2 file

1 2
5 6
Post subject: Movie published
TASVideoAgent
They/Them
Moderator
Joined: 8/3/2004
Posts: 14857
Location: 127.0.0.1
This movie has been published. The posts before this message apply to the submission, and posts after this message apply to the published movie. ---- [1577] NES The Legend of Zelda "Swordless Challenge" by jprofit22 in 26:40.33
Joined: 9/12/2009
Posts: 60
Location: None of Your Business, USA
I'm not sure I am all for the goal of "Swordless except for Ganon." But I love the new glitches. Im going with MEH
NitroGenesis
He/Him
Editor, Experienced player (551)
Joined: 12/24/2009
Posts: 1873
Are there any new tricks or whatever that could be used to improve the normal zelda movie, or are they just strictly swordless? sorry, if this has been answered I wasn't really following this topic (don't shoot me, jprofit22)
YoungJ1997lol wrote:
Normally i would say Yes, but thennI thought "its not the same hack" so ill stick with meh.
Joined: 7/8/2009
Posts: 43
Location: Catalonia
zelda 1 tas are usually boring, but this run is amazing and funny. congratulations!!!
Skilled player (1402)
Joined: 5/31/2004
Posts: 1821
Nice to see this accepted and published. After the Outlands ordeal, I don't think I would have the courage to make this... good to see people enjoyed it :) The exact goals aren't too clear to me though. I was wondering... which of the following would disqualify a movie from being an improvement to this movie? 1) Collecting one or more heart containers 2) Collecting other items, such as boomerang, magic key, bracelet etc. 3) Collecting the sword earlier, but still using it only for Ganon 4) Not collecting the sword but freezing the screen at Ganon with the freezing glitch Although I have an opinion, I'm not particularly arguing for one or the other... just curious about the precise restrictions.
Banned User, Former player
Joined: 3/10/2004
Posts: 7698
Location: Finland
Baxter wrote:
1) Collecting one or more heart containers 2) Collecting other items, such as boomerang, magic key, bracelet etc. 3) Collecting the sword earlier, but still using it only for Ganon 4) Not collecting the sword but freezing the screen at Ganon with the freezing glitch
Personally I greatly dislike the idea of freezing the game before it's completed. TASing is about completing games (which can be completed). If the goal is "get to Ganon without using the sword, and only then use it", I'd say anything goes which achieves that goal. It doesn't really matter what you do, as long as that goal is strictly achieved.
adelikat
He/Him
Emulator Coder, Site Developer, Site Owner, Expert player (3584)
Joined: 11/3/2004
Posts: 4738
Location: Tennessee
Warp wrote:
If the goal is "get to Ganon without using the sword, and only then use it", I'd say anything goes which achieves that goal. It doesn't really matter what you do, as long as that goal is strictly achieved.
However, I don't think that the choice of how to achieve that should be based on how many frames each option takes; which seems to be what Baxter is implying.
It's hard to look this good. My TAS projects
Banned User, Former player
Joined: 3/10/2004
Posts: 7698
Location: Finland
adelikat wrote:
Warp wrote:
If the goal is "get to Ganon without using the sword, and only then use it", I'd say anything goes which achieves that goal. It doesn't really matter what you do, as long as that goal is strictly achieved.
However, I don't think that the choice of how to achieve that should be based on how many frames each option takes; which seems to be what Baxter is implying.
Why not? What else, then? Wouldn't it be sloppy play if frames were wasted?
Player (142)
Joined: 7/16/2009
Posts: 686
If the goal is to do everything except the Ganon fight without using the sword, should you not simply collect the sword en do everything else in the most optimal way? I don't see how these options have anything to do with optimization.
Joined: 7/2/2007
Posts: 3960
Stylistically it looks better if you don't have the sword for the vast majority of the game. At least, that's my opinion. This would be a speed/entertainment tradeoff.
Pyrel - an open-source rewrite of the Angband roguelike game in Python.
Skilled player (1402)
Joined: 5/31/2004
Posts: 1821
What about the heartcontainers and possible extra items (boomerang, etc)?
Player (142)
Joined: 7/16/2009
Posts: 686
Baxter wrote:
What about the heartcontainers and possible extra items (boomerang, etc)?
They're not swords, so I don't see any reason you wouldn't be allowed to collect them.
snorlax
He/Him
Joined: 5/20/2007
Posts: 174
Location: Wisconsin
I would say feel free to collect as many heart containers and other items as you want, but leave the swordless qualifications as they are now. I'd rather see an improved regular first quest run first though. And welcome back.
Active player (422)
Joined: 9/27/2004
Posts: 650
Location: Canada
Derakon wrote:
Stylistically it looks better if you don't have the sword for the vast majority of the game. At least, that's my opinion. This would be a speed/entertainment tradeoff.
The sword is collected directly after a save/restart anyway, so getting it sooner shouldn't be faster at all. At least, that's my assumption. I'm no Zelda 1 expert, maybe something I don't know about makes it slower or faster. BUT if it's true, getting the sword where this run does isn't really a speed/entertainment tradeoff at all--just getting the sword sooner is less entertaining. Maybe only subjectively less entertaining, but I'm pretty sure actually having nothing in the A button box looks more interesting than having a sword there and never pressing A. Getting it later (ie, two trips into level 9) would be a speed/entertainment tradeoff but it seems pretty silly to me. I don't think playing level 9 twice in a row is entertaining, and I would definately stop watching after the first trip. I'm not sure where I would stand on never picking up the sword, getting to the end and then freezing the game or dying or something. But I don't really want to worry about that because overall I'm okay with what this run did. Boy did this part of this post ever get rambly. Oh well.
Baxter wrote:
What about the heartcontainers and possible extra items (boomerang, etc)?
If any other item is collected then that's fine, it keeps to the original challenge. If it's faster, then great. Do it. But if it's slower what's the point?
Editor, Publisher, Player (46)
Joined: 10/15/2021
Posts: 370
1 2
5 6