This topic is for the purpose of discussing #5902: Hoandjzj's SNES Super Metroid: Kaizo Edition in 1:17:59.24

I was going to say something about this totally serious run, but then I finished watching it.

there are some very smart ideas in this hack; it would be fun if actual SM players would try to play this without being spoiled.....

Some serious feedback: this started out pretty tedious, but got more enjoyable as it went on. The visuals of the level design are a bit bland, and of course it's got that kaizo thing going on where things don't really look like they seem, but it's interesting to see the character progression as areas go from "really repetitive" to "trivially solved" as they're encountered repeatedly from time to time over the run. The game also manages to have a "sense of place"; despite the map being rather different from Super Metroid's and unfamiliar to me, it didn't take me long to get a sense of how things were connected and to recognise areas that the character had been in before. It's a pity that the start has so many repetitive sequences (especially slowly moving through bombable corridors a bomb at a time), because the middle-to-end is pretty fun to watch. (I'm assuming that you got the intended ending of the game? It's often hard to tell what counts as a win in a Kaizo game.)

It might be worthwhile to point out that the actual ending (if one plays back the movie) doesn't contain this death at the ship and instead as usual advances to the credits, which was edited in the video.

As far as I'm concerned, this is plenty entertaining enough for Moons. Yes vote.

This hack must contain some of my least favorite level design for Super Metroid romhacks: Long morphball mazes, copious underwater sections, and a ton of backtracking. I think the section where you had to slowly bomb your way through a long morphball tunnel coming back from Norfair was the worst offender. Thankfully, with each new item that you got, the backtracking sections got a little bit faster, and I enjoyed seeing the different strategies used to traverse the rooms. Overall, I'm erring on the side of "Meh" in terms of entertainment on this run. On the one hand, it's Super Metroid, and I can't get enough of that, on the other hand, as a TAS, it is very slow and tedious. Great work though, do keep it up nonetheless.

It might be worthwhile to point out that the actual ending (if one plays back the movie) doesn't contain this death at the ship and instead as usual advances to the credits, which was edited in the video.

oowwww and i seriously tought that the game would actually game over when you reach the ship just to screw even more with the poor dude that lost his mind actually trying to tackle the game i'm so sad :(

In the video, I think it would be infinitely cooler to see the boss in question without any text showing up that spoils said boss. I watched the whole thing. I guess that counts for something.

I agree with ais523 and scrimpeh that some of the maps were very tedious to watch Samus traverse. That's poor level design in my opinion. But I noticed little things that you did to make these parts more entertaining, and you also used new items nearly every time you were forced through that messy map in the first half. But overall, I was entertained. I normally would not watch Metroid for that long, but there were some nail-biting moments when you would nearly run out of health (down to one HP at one point) only to kill an enemy for more at just the right frame. Good work!

Much as I enjoy Super Metroid, I must say this is a poorly designed romhack with an overreliance on bland design, walls that act as passages, and simply sticking spikes everywhere. Furthermore, a google search suggests that it is sorely lacking in notability, getting only a couple hundred hits where Super Metroid Impossible and Super Zero Mission get tens of thousands. There are over a hundred Super Metroid hacks and I fail to see what's so special about this one. Voting no.

I think this might a good time to revisit this judgment, if such a thing is feasible. The notoriety of the hack has gone up a lot in the last month or so, mostly from streamer Oatsngoats speedrunning the hack (albeit a slightly modified version to be more RTA-friendly.)

From what I remembered when this was posted, I didn’t really find it all that interesting, there’s alot of arbitrary movement required to get around each area, which makes it hard to watch most of the time. Though maybe others will feel differently about it.