This topic is for the purpose of discussing #2291: SDR's Arcade X-Men vs. Street Fighter in 11:38.38

I watched the video on youtube earlier today, awesome stuff. Fighting movies are usually boring but this one somehow entertained me. Yes vote.

And that's how I believe fighting game TAS should be done. Not about just showing techniques and combos, but doing it with style. Literally "playing around" with the game, showing how quirky the A.I. can be, choosing wisely which characters should appear in the movie, and showing as much as the game has to offer without getting bored. In Mortal Kombat series (expect 1) it's easier, just choose Shang Tsung and do whatever you like. I believe you chose well. A good match of CPU and 2P fights, interesting characters (when you picked Juggernaut I thought it would suck a lot, then it all made sense in the fight). I read in some places that Magneto and Storm are cheap in this game, and if it's right, not choosing them was great too. The run had some twists too, and that's amazing. I thought, when I first saw, that the run would be predictable, with chacracters just tagging for kicks, then Juggernaut and Ken surprised me. Strong yes vote

This was pretty awesome. Yes vote just for ass kicking.

Sometimes you did a combo over and over and over again. IIRC Cyclops was one of the characters who had that problem. Too lazy to look again. Because of that point, however, I will vote meh on an entertaining movie.

I was entertained. However, because of my unfamiliarity with fighting games, I will abstain from voting.

Pretty much what OmegaWatcher said: there was more style, and less infinite juggling. Moreover, MVSF is clearly a game better suited for TASing than the SFA series, with its tag system and faster-paced action. This submission blows away the other SF TASes, IMO. Yes vote.

Yes vote, this is a big improvement over your previous submissions. A couple of repeated combos here and there, but those were the only things that niggled me. A pretty entertaining watch.

This was a really good run, I enjoyed it thoroughly even without knowing the game all that much. It seemed to get better and better combo-wise as you progressed. I'd say this could be deemed a 'many aspects' run what with all the speedy combos, all the characters being used (I think that's all of them), and other stuff to fit the criteria (the after-round hits done occasionally, and showing off all the specials/supers/whatevers, etc.). So yeah, nice run SDR. Keep on TASing. Yes vote.

This time... it was great Lot of fun in there, the whole run is entertaining, show lot of stuffs too, i particulary laughted hard at the "old" trick from streetfighter2'' when you fly off screen with juggernault/chunli You earned my yes vote, it was nice effort, very cool movie

I'm impressed with this one, nice work, easy Yes for sure, and by the way, as Jubilee says: Is he hard-core or what?

Awww... I was kinda sad that it ended in a draw game. I was looking forward to watching Apocalypse get ripped to shreds. Well-played, though, and entertaining to watch. I just forgot how much I hated the character portraits from that era of Capcom fighters. But that doesn't detract from the movie itself, so thumbs up. I doubt this will be published, because it can't be categorized, but I still say it's entertaining.[/spoiler]

I doubt this will be published, because it can't be categorized

Concept Demos.

I'm aware of concept demos, I've made the argument in the past. Though I don't think anything I've supported in favor of being published in concept demos has actually made it there, so... [edit] Nevermind, I think the 'glitchfest' All-Stars SMB3 was one I supported for concept demos. >.>

congratulation SDR, easy yes vote, this movie is realy entertaining i realy liked the way how you used differents characters to kill the repetitiveness, realy good job the draw was kinda surprising too... i'm sad tought that you didn't used the gambit triple fury who goes to 99Hits too but the chun-li one is realy a highlight of the run ! perseverence is the first of a TASser quality, don't give up and try to TAS other kind of games, don't stay focused on fighting ones...

Awww... I was kinda sad that it ended in a draw game.

I guess you watched only the first part of it...

Ah, didn't catch it was in multiple parts. >.>;

It is better than all your previous runs, SDR. It was a nice balance of entertainment and speed. I vote yes because I was entertained by the run.

Ah, didn't catch it was in multiple parts. >.>;

Me either. I stream videos through a shell script instead of actually following the links. There was nothing to suggest otherwise in the submission text, so I assumed the double KO was the ending. I'm glad it wasn't though, because we get to see Cammy. :p

Giggles and enjoyment all round, even from my brother who doesn't really like fighting games. Yes.

I liked the Juggernaut vs Chun Li fight Yes vote. Will Marvel vs Capcom be done next?

Pretty surprised at some of the things you did in (or, did to) that game. I was a little annoyed at the amount of "fighting yourself," but the results were amusing enough that I am willing to concede the point. Generally interesting combo action, some good variability in the way you used them, with just enough supers thrown into the mix. Also, you finished the thing with my favorite super finish. How can I not vote Yes?

I was a little annoyed at the amount of "fighting yourself,"

Interesting, I've been pushing for more of this sort of action a lot in fighting game movies. My argument goes something like "one god vs. one god can be more entertaining than one god vs. a flawed AI".